iane
Full Member
Posts: 19
|
Post by iane on Oct 6, 2015 6:47:15 GMT 1
Hello everyone! Long time no see - I hope that you are all well, and I also hope you can help me out with a little problem I am facing. So you sure have heard about the huge numbers of refugees that came and come to Europe. I have volunteered with refugees for a while now, and while I try not talk about it much, sometimes people find out and feel the need to express their opinion towards me. One person in particular that is expressing her opinion not only towards me, but also towards a large facebook crowd is a good old friend of mine - and she is also a Buddhist. I honestly don't know how to deal with her moslem-hating tirades - claiming they are in majority criminals and rapists, that they will try to introduce Sharia law in our country, and that we should best all put them in prisons until they have proven otherwise. I know, the best advice is probably not feeding this, and usually I don't engage in any sort of conversation like this, but break the contact because I feel it is pointless. I feel makes me very agitated to even engage in any sort of conversation. However, this view on Islam is not just the view of this individual, but based on the view of the Buddhist leader of the group she follows - Lama Ole Nydahl. Unfortunately, their group is not a small group - in fact, Ole Nydahl managed to make this the most prevalent form of Buddhism in Germany. I think you can read about him on the controversy page. And a huge number of his followers agrees with his rants against Islam. So I feel a little bit in a bind here. As volunteers, we are actually encouraged to speak out against any form of racism (which this clearly is) in order to demonstrate that the loud-mouths are not alone but there are other voices as well. On the other hand, I feel like engaging in conversation with that friend is not going to change her long held believes, and it is only making us both even more stuck in our ways. In our conversations, I try to stay calm and just bring up facts and appeal to her compassion towards all sentient beings. But I have to admit - there is also some "Ego" problem, in that I don't like that people here perceive Buddhism to hold such racist views, and being thrown in one pot with them. What should I do? So far, our "conversations" have been mostly through facebook and chatting, mostly because I am not sure if I am skillful enough to remain calm in a phone conversation (we live quite a distance apart - We used to be really good friends, but we have grown apart due to the distance). Do you think I should just let it go? Maybe it is all about me "being right"? Please advise Thanks for reading this, and any input would be highly appreciated! iane
|
|
matt
Senior Member
Posts: 425
|
Post by matt on Oct 8, 2015 0:11:52 GMT 1
First of all, thank you for helping the refugees! That is really positive work, and it is sorely needed. In my experience it can be very rewarding as well, you get to meet and eventually to know some remarkable people who have a unique perspective.
What you describe is a really hard situation. Karma reveals itself as habitual tendencies. So your friend has karma that is disturbing her mind and causing her to project her own negativity on Muslums. This is probably part of what attracts her to Ole Nydahl, because he has the same issues.
I don't believe you will change her mind. As much as you do talk to her, then it is fine to attempt to be a positive influence, but as it is also upsetting you, then that too is karma, your karma revealing itself, in my opinion. So I think the wise approach is to disentangle yourself from her as much as you can, and forget about changing her mind, focusing instead on changing yours--in other words continuing the effort to have and maintain peace of mind.
A peaceful mind is a more skillful mind, and eventually you may be surprised at how easily you can influence this kind of negativity. In the meantime, you are having a really positive impact on the lives of people who desperately need it. I would advise you to concentrate on that and make a real effort to let go of this disturbing person and her wrong views.
I think the advice from the refugee group to speak up is only good advice in certain situations, when you can do so calmly, with compassion and without competitiveness. It will probably be a while before that becomes anything but a rare occurrence. It isn't just that the discussion disturbs your mind, but that people who have intolerance get entrenched and defensive when challenged or disagreed with, and hearing the right view may have the opposite effect on them than what is desired.
|
|
iane
Full Member
Posts: 19
|
Post by iane on Oct 9, 2015 20:24:44 GMT 1
Hello Matt, thank you very much for your kind reply. Yes, helping the refugees is indeed very rewarding. You get to meet really interesting people from all over, and all of them have a unique story to tell. I try to be aware what it does to me, because I think it can very easily also become an Ego-trip where you do it in order to feel good about yourself. About my problem with that friend: I think you are absolutely right, I won't change other people's mind, and I should focus on my own mind and negativity that came up in that context. It is not doing me any good to become upset about it. I *feel* like I might be able to stay calm and compassionate in a conversation with her, but I am not entirely sure, and the general intention might still be the "being right". I notice that I have made tremendous progress in respect to not becoming defensive and agressive in discussions in the last few years. But there is still a long way to go I think, and I am not ready for this kind of test yet . It is very good that you are reminding me of the reasons why that situation presents itself for her and for me right now. It's actually very obvious, but well, I apparently forgot for a moment... It shows that my practise is not firm enough yet, when things only seem clear and obvious as long as you sit on your cushion . I will use these opportunities of her ranting to discern my emotions, and instead of mentally condemning her for not being compassionate, I will try and generate some more compassion for her. Thank you again. iane.
|
|
|
Post by Jeff H on Oct 11, 2015 14:30:21 GMT 1
Thank you both! This is one of the best exchanges I've read in a Buddhist forum. It is quite inspiring to me.
|
|
iane
Full Member
Posts: 19
|
Post by iane on Oct 12, 2015 19:59:20 GMT 1
Awww, thanks Jeff! A few days ago, Venerable Thubten Chödron had a really nice talk on her Bodhisattva's Breakfast Corner on the qualities of the Buddha that I wanted to share. She was also talking about the speech of a Buddha (starting around 8 minutes into the video), and what she said resonated with me and what you said: that even though we might have the right motivation, the words don't come out of our mouths in the right way, or are not received as we intended, and they can cause disharmony. The Buddha has the finesse to say the right thing at the right time and can affect people. Most of us don't yet, but it is something to be aspired . I found that very interesting. Thanks again to you guys! iane
|
|
matt
Senior Member
Posts: 425
|
Post by matt on Oct 16, 2015 3:52:21 GMT 1
Thanks to you two as well. That was a good question Iane. You always have interesting things to say.
|
|
tamara
Senior Member
Posts: 178
|
Post by tamara on Nov 10, 2015 1:46:06 GMT 1
Hello Iane,
I saw Lama Ole Nydahl in 1996 in Vienna/Austria in a talk he gave. His talk and way to deal with things has further prompted my interest in Buddhism. Thank you Lama Ole Nydahl…..
Few years ago I discovered that he established a meditation center + Sangha just 10 minutes from where I lived as a child in horribly un-spiritual communist times. Thank you Lama Ole Nydahl for being one of the first or perhaps the first who dared to bring Buddhism to spiritually starved eastern Europe.
I have followed his teachings from time to time afterwards to see what`s new and how he presents the Dharma. What I heard is that `Islam is a threat`, never heard direct negative talk against Islam as such. Perhaps his approach has changed now and this would be a distressing thing to hear.
As for Germany: I am watching the Buddhist scene since years and the time where Lama Ole Nydahl was a leading figure seems to be over. There are many other teachers and masters to be chosen from. Still not sufficient though, but it develops in the right direction.
Iane, what you describe in your messages made me smile. No wonder Jeff finds it a fascinating exchange. What you describe is kind of a metaphor of what we human beings are going through day by day. Sometimes there are more peaceful times, sometimes rough ones.
What you describe is exactly the challenge we have in daily lives: To skillfully work with circumstances and how difficult it is. And to forgive oneself if one (again) could not manage it the way one wanted to but created confusion and negativity instead. Keep going, definitely you`re going in the right direction and the fact that you are diligently working on this issue is amazing and incredibly precious. Many if not most people do NOT take all these pains but numb themselves with what is readily available.
``the words don't come out of our mouths in the right way, or are not received as we intended, and they can cause disharmony. ``
Definitely that`s the point. There`s only one way to deal with it and Matt explained it eloquently. To stay focused when the other person`s words make you upset is a skill which can be practiced. Be grateful to everybody who makes you practice it.
Keeping fingers crossed for you, Iane.
Greetings from somebody who lives in `inter-cultural tension` since earliest childhood and whose daily task it is to make people understand each other and let go of their pain, aggression. I went through all the stages from aggression and cynicism in my early years to much more skillful means from my 30ies onward. Nowadays, at the age of 55, I mostly focus on intervention in disputes and am very grateful to do so with some positive result.
Keep on going, Iane.
Tamara
|
|
iane
Full Member
Posts: 19
|
Post by iane on Jan 8, 2016 7:34:37 GMT 1
Dear Tamara, thank you so much for your kind words, and thank you for keeping your fingers crossed for me Yes, you are right, Ole Nydahl did indeed get a lot of people in contact with Buddhism over here, so that is something. I found it very interesting what you wrote about numbing yourself instead of taking on the pain, because that is something that I am currently definitely NOT doing in respect to other aspects of my life . Maybe I will write about it separately and ask for your advice later... iane
|
|
|
Post by csee on Aug 1, 2016 5:49:30 GMT 1
Perhaps as one awaken to Buddhism , one realized he is constantly alone as emotion , nothing is connected or related to him except just providing a great source of realization to him ..... so basically you are emotion and Buddhism is simply a natural process realizing that ....the lady is just like a mirror reflecting your emotion back to you , the emotion that you notice is actually a great source for your own realization on the emotion in your mind .
The lady is a teacher to you providing a great source of realization ... there never is ' a need" to change anyone to be what you think should be ... you just live with the emotion and share it with others ... as such others will learn from it as you are learning it from others including yourself .]
Buddhism is all about you , not the knowledge that you hold .
|
|
iane
Full Member
Posts: 19
|
Post by iane on Nov 3, 2016 8:31:44 GMT 1
Dear Csee, That's an interesting way of putting it, Thank you! And sorry for my late-late reply to it, I really appreciate all your input. I have distanced myself a bit from the whole thing (literally left the country), and it is interesting for me to see now how strongly I saw myself as part of a group and had a strong Ego thing going in which I wanted to defend my views and probably wanted to prove others wrong. I totally did not perceive this as strongly when I first wrote this post, but now it is becoming more obvious. Thanks for giving me the opportunity to reflect on this! Sometimes my thoughts and views seem so permanent, but they, too, are a dependent arising Cheers, Iane
|
|